Skip to content
Ask Claude about any Chrome extension, answered with Ext Watch data. See how →
Compare · dark mode extensions

Charcoal vs After Dark Mode

Two of the most used dark mode extensions for Chrome, side by side on store figures.

Start freeNo credit card needed
  • 100K+UsersTie100K+
  • 4.08 ★408 ratingsRatingof 5No rating

Charcoal leads on fewer permissionsTie on users

Scorecard

Every store fact, side by side

Users, ratings, reviews and access, as the Chrome Web Store shows them.

CompareStore figures, checked daily · Leads marks the better side; level facts are unmarked
Store factsUsers, rating, reviews, access and listing
CharcoalAndrew Millman
Unofficial Messenger dark mode. Easily swap between dark and light mode.
After Dark ModeAfter Dark
Change your default search engine for afterdarkmode.com
UsersCharcoal: Dark Mode for Messenger:100K+After Dark Mode:100K+
Ratingmarked with 20+ ratingsCharcoal: Dark Mode for Messenger:4.08 ★ 408 ratingsAfter Dark Mode:3.86 ★ 7 ratings
API permissionsCharcoal: Dark Mode for Messenger:1LeadsAfter Dark Mode:2
Website accessCharcoal: Dark Mode for Messenger:No website accessAfter Dark Mode:1 site pattern
Access leveldata it can reachCharcoal: Dark Mode for Messenger:LowAfter Dark Mode:Low
Featured on the storeCharcoal: Dark Mode for Messenger:★ FeaturedAfter Dark Mode:★ Featured
Store categoryCharcoal: Dark Mode for Messenger:AccessibilityAfter Dark Mode:Tools
MoreFull listing Alternatives Full listing Alternatives

Last updated, version and package size · for both, in the app's compare

Start free
Permissions

Who asks for what

Each permission either one requests, by name, with what it allows.

Charcoal1 API permissions
After Dark Mode2 API permissions

Sensitive: reaches your data or other sites.

Only Charcoal0

Charcoal asks for nothing that After Dark Mode does not.

Both ask for1

  • storageSave its own settings

Only After Dark Mode1

  • declarativeNetRequestBlock or redirect requests with set rules
Both ask for1
  • storageSave its own settings
Website accessNo website access1 site patternhttps://afterdarkmode.com/*

Sensitive: reaches your data or other sites. Requested access describes what an extension can do, not what its developer intends. It does not say whether an extension is safe.

In dark mode extensions

Where they sit among dark mode extensions

Ranked by store users, with other head-to-heads beside them.

Dark mode extensionsRanked by store users
  1. 1Dark ReaderDark Reader Ltd7M+★ 4.3
  2. 2Dark ModeGrephy2M+★ 3.6
  3. 3Google Docs Dark ModeOchoa Hidalgo900K+★ 3.1
  4. 4Dark ThemeDark-Shiftmode.com500K+★ 4.3
  5. 5Dark ModePROMOTINO OOD300K+★ 4.6
  6. 6CharcoalAndrew Millman100K+★ 4.1
  7. 7After Dark ModeAfter Dark100K+★ 3.9
  8. 8Dark ThemeDark Theme Web90K+★ 3.9
  9. 9Lunar Readerlunarreader.com80K+★ 4.6
  10. 10Dark ReaderDarkReader60K+★ 4.2
20 dark mode extensions on the listSee the full list
Questions

Common questions

  1. 01

    Which is better, Charcoal or After Dark Mode?

    On store figures: Charcoal leads on fewer permissions; they are level on users. The right pick depends on the features you need.

  2. 02

    Do both run on every website?

    No. Charcoal: no website access. After Dark Mode: 1 site pattern.

  3. 03

    Is either one featured on the Chrome Web Store?

    Both carry the store's Featured badge.

297,753 Chrome extensions in one place

Track Charcoal and After Dark Mode on Radar

One email when their users, rating or permissions change.

No credit card neededFree ExplorerAsk Claude about any extension